How is a confusion possible between Western and Russian Attitude When leaders like Putin walk past, they tilt their heads at jaunty Click here to find more about the telnyashka and why paratroopers started wearing it too. But it appears to be different on the Russian side. Since in recent years the date has also been the day of Russian presidential inaugurations, the new President of Russia, following his oath-taking ceremony, receives the salute of the regiment on this day. By clicking Post Your Answer, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy. The horizon line is what's moving on a Western instrument, and this is what might confuse pilot. In Russia's military, a culture of brutality runs deep | CNN 1 Dogs tilt their heads when they're paying attention to you Credit: Getty It means that while the quizzical head cock might give off an air of confusion, it's actually a sign of raised attention. On January 28, 1936, the battalion and the Kremlin Garrison (Komendatura Kremlya), to which it was subordinated were transferred from the People's Commissariat of Defense of the USSR to the People's Commissariat of Internal Affairs (NKVD) of the USSR. They also tend to use maps with 'track up' orientation. Russian soldiers have been told they are there to liberate Russian-speaking Ukrainians from a genocidal Nazi regime bent on eradicating their language, culture, and identity. However, when, for example, President Vladimir Putin, dressed in civilian clothing, is saluted, he doesnt return the salute, because he is not in uniform and isnt wearing military headwear (unlike the U.S. President, for example). Essentially, a military salute is a sign of peaceful intentions a military person is showing that the right hand is open and free of any weapon. , (1997) (1999), - ", ".: : ", " ", Presidential Regiment archive.kremlin.ru, Kremlin Guards Don Spacesuits In Battle Against Winter Weather, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Kremlin_Regiment&oldid=1105956200, Military units and formations of the NKVD, Military units and formations established in 1936, Short description is different from Wikidata, Articles containing Russian-language text, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License 3.0, Presidential Cavalry Escort Battalion, Kremlin Regiment (former 11th Cavalry Regiment), 4th Operational Reserve Battalion, Kremlin Regiment, This page was last edited on 22 August 2022, at 15:01. How will you be able to look your children in the eyes. Russian President Vladimir Putin enters the Alexadrovsky Hall to head a meeting of the Presidential Council for Civil Society and Human Rights at the Kremlin in Moscow, Russia, on Oct. 1, 2015. The roots of Russia's invasion of Ukraine go back decades and run deep. Also, some objects were to be saluted: the Lenin Mausoleum, the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier, mass graves of the soldiers perished defending the Fatherland, all military banners and standards, as well as funeral processions accompanied by troops. This visual echo would have confirmed, for the Russian public back home, Russias official explanation for the invasion: the denazification of Ukraine. Captured Russian soldiers reportedly said they were misled about the purpose of the war in Ukraine. What is becoming clear as the war in Ukraine unfolds is that the ideological ground Russia has laid for it is fragile. In their government? Why do Russian guards tilt their head and watch when leaders walk past? Victoria Smolkin is associate professor ofhistory atWesleyanUniversity and the author of ASacredSpaceIs Never Empty: AHistoryof Soviet Atheism. They were first introduced in the mid-19th century, You can find all information on the Defense Ministrys. What types of attitude indicators are there? Indeed, it is precisely this cultural proximity that seems to be having a powerful effect on Russian military morale. This possibility for confusion is one reason among several why many pilots prefer the traditional "turn rate indicator" (aka "turn and slip indicator") to the "turn coordinator"-- despite the fact that by sensing roll as well as yaw, the "turn coordinator" tends to give a stronger indication than the turn rate indicator when an aircraft first starts to roll into an unwanted turn. Vladimir Andreeff, a man who says he is a Russian army veteran, says this is all part of the standard "military greeting". He walks up this long stairway lined with soldiers holding their rifles at the salute, and as he Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, and our products. By clicking Accept all cookies, you agree Stack Exchange can store cookies on your device and disclose information in accordance with our Cookie Policy. That means that you are clearly rolling right. This means all soldiers must look at a certain mark, most common are Alignment to the left / right / tribune / commander. - What is this odd military salute-like gesture? Thanks for sharing this experience, but how come that these (Western) aircraft had 'Russian' FAI? June 29, 2017. On May 7, 1965 it was decorated with the Order of the Red Banner for its military achievements during the Great Patriotic War. The mental picture of motion is different for different people. Why do Putin's soldiers and Praetorian Guards have their heads In September 1918, the Latvian Riflemen left for the fronts of the Civil War, and they were replaced by the officer cadets of the 1st WPKA Soviet Joint Military School "All-Russian Central Executive Committee" that were redeployed into the Kremlin for this purpose. Go home with a clear conscience; Putin has lost. Are there rules for shortening words? Russian Bloems a movement disorders specialist and he and some colleagues had briefly wondered if it might be Parkinsons disease, which can cause stiff movements. Is "I didn't think it was serious" usually a good defence against "duty to rescue"? There are a couple of reasons for ceremonial hats being so big (and no, its not because Russians have oversized heads). This helps make it clear that the symbology employed in the device is actually following the same presentation as is employed in the Russian-style artificial horizon, which is also the same presentation as is employed in a "turn coordinator". Russia Why do Russian soldiers hold their head at a weird angle while Russian soldiers I'd rather +1 with this - technically it counts as, @Quassnoi as far as I know (but I'm not a military person and can be wrong) it's still, - - - . Here's an example https://focus.ua/files/images/0/-87397.jpg Soldiers here were given a command to align to tribune and salute the president. What happens when they encounter reality on the ground in Ukraine? Do they understand what they are fighting for? We were struck to find several consecutive YouTube recordings of Russias president, Vladimir Putin, manifesting a clearly reduced right-sided arm swing, Bloem and colleagues wrote in The BMJ, the British Medical Journals online publication which just happens to be running tongue-in-cheek holiday stories this week. "Portrait of Count Alexander Suvorov" by Joseph Kreutzinger. The upper instrument is the Western display, the bottom one is the "Russian". Yet confusion could arise when a pilot used to seeing the Western style artificial horizon, where the moving thing is the horizon not the airplane, assumes the moving on the Russian style is also the horizon, not the airplane. WebAnswer (1 of 5): It actually has nothing to do with Putin or Presidential Regiment. On May 8, 1967 the regiment took part in the unveiling ceremony of the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier in the Alexander Garden. But what about Russian soldiers? WebWhy do Russian soldiers hold their head at a weird angle while saluting or while at attention. Without a stronger sense of moral justification, Putin may soon find that despite his arsenal and tanks, the Russian army lacks the morale to do what it would take to win a war against Ukrainians. The country boasts a number of military systems and some equipment that, without doubt, areunrivalled. This confusion is also suggested to play a part in. The old tradition of giving military salute only when the head is covered is still preserved. ), the military salute is given by standing at attention. This corresponds to the direct ('Western') indication, and such people must adapt to it more naturally. The whole world is with Ukraine! Last Updated: 3rd April, 2022 07:22 IST Ukraine Says Heads Of Women POWs Shaved Bald, Accuses Russia Of 'Nazi Move' It was reported that the prisoners of war (POWs) from both Ukraine and Russia have returned to their countries after they were detained during the fighting. Produced by Will Reid and Michael Simon Johnson. What Does Russia's Partial Military Mobilization Mean? @Claudix, the image used in your original question can be misleading for 2 reasons: Both instruments are tilted to the right side on your original image. How is a confusion possible between Western and Russian Attitude Indicators? In By clicking Accept all cookies, you agree Stack Exchange can store cookies on your device and disclose information in accordance with our Cookie Policy. Archived post. No hand gestures are made. 10,000 hours later and I still sometimes get tripped up. The exact same source of confusion often arises when a pilot who is used to focusing his attention mainly on the (Western style) attitude indicator tries to fly primarily by reference to the "turn coordinator"- where the moving thing is the airplane, not the horizon. A boy can regenerate, so demons eat him for years. Uniforms based on the ones used by the infantry of the Regiment during the Second World War were worn for the first time by a platoon from the 1st Honor Guard Company during the 2015 Spasskaya Tower Military Music Festival and Tattoo. 122 for the Moscow Kremlin Garrison, the Special Purpose Battalion became the Special Purpose Regiment; this day is considered the birthday of the regiment. There are several explanations for this. They saw the same strange gait in Prime Minister Dmitry Medvedev, two former defense ministers and a military commander named Anatoly Sidorov. Go back to your family!; Do not become a murderer. Perhaps the most powerful book to address this question was Christopher Brownings Ordinary Men: Reserve Police Battalion 101 and the Final Solution in Poland. Why do Russian guards tilt their head and watch when leaders walk Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search. But, honor is a mutual affair and those officers who do not return the salute given to them by the lower ranks, do a bad thing, for they show that they are less well-bred than the soldiers and, in addition, give the soldiers an example of non-compliance with the regulations. Top 5 most Googled questions about the Russian army In contrast, on the Russian instrument, the aircraft silhouette is moving in front of a static horizon. Leave without blood on your hands; Instead of flowers, bullets await you. Enjoy watching this other masterpiece by Russian troops. Russia Ukraine Crisis | Written By Rohit Ranjan Image: On September 2, 2002 on the basis of the 11th Cavalry Regiment (the Moscow Military District movie-making cavalry unit) a cavalry escort unit was formed as part of the Presidential Regiment. I wonder who came up with the idea to show the bank indicator arrow at the opposite side of the bank. What means of navigation did commercial Soviet airplanes use in the 50s-90s? While carrying a rifle or a naked sabre, the soldiers were to put the weapon on their shoulders. "Apartments were blown up in Moscow, like they were terrorists.". In both models, if you see the indicators turning your head right (as if you were sat on the plane's seat), both show that the right wing is "touching" ground. I find that a weird graphic. The pilots were manually flying in a busy phase of flight. In 19421943 four groups of snipers from the Kremlin Regiment were sent to the Western and Volkhov Fronts. Three battalions from the regiment took part in the Moscow Victory Parade of 1945 on Red Square. WebThe Kremlin Regiment, a group of special guards tasked with protecting high-profile Russian leaders, seem a bit odd.When leaders like Putin walk past, they tilt their heads at jaunty angles and watch them walking.You can only really get a sense of what it is like when you watch a Click here to find out more. WebHere is a selection of clips of Vladimir Putin walking at various engagements over the past month. The historical dress uniform is a closed-collar tunic with a cornflower blue plastron, whereas the modern dress uniform is an open-collar jacket with a white dress shirt and tie. Is there a word or phrase in Russian for this particular salute-like gesture? What is this odd military salute-like gesture? Milgrams volunteers were given the role of teacher and told that the experiment was a study of whether pain improved memory. They found killing Jewish civilians who spoke German, like them, especially difficult. The fate of Putins war in Ukraine depends on how ordinary Russian soldiers react to what they find on the ground. The Presidential Band of the Russian Federation serves as the official military band for the President of Russia, playing at official ceremonies and receptions for high-ranking officials. In Russia, the salute was to be performed solely when the head was covered with military headwear. First of all, they need enough space to accommodate Russias military heraldic crest, which is bigger than the Soviet red star. Is a downhill scooter lighter than a downhill MTB with same performance? He also rips off an arm to use as a sword. Such commanders and persons included: all members of the Imperial family, generals, admirals, garrison commanders, commanders of regiments, escadrons, staff officers and also while passing by state banners and standards (flags). This should also shed some light on the reverse question.